The Unseen Toll
-
Baldwin’s letter is a warning to his nephew, James. He explains that Black children grow up in a society that often devalues them, implicitly or explicitly teaching them that they are less capable, less deserving, and less human than their white peers. He wants James to understand that the world will not change easily, and that many of the people who oppress him will be "innocent and well-meaning." He writes, "Most of them do not yet really know that you exist." This ignorance, however, is not an excuse for the harm they cause, he asserts. Their ignorance is the crime they are committing. It is a willful blindness to the realities of Black suffering and the systems that sustain it. By refusing to confront the truth about racism, white Americans protect their own sense of innocence and righteousness, allowing them to continue benefiting from a system that marginalizes Black people while maintaining the illusion that they are "good" or "just" people.
The task for James, then, Baldwin writes, is not only to survive in the world but to understand the complexity of white innocence and find a way to move beyond it. Baldwin’s call to accept white people "with love" is not a plea for submission or hyperbole. It is for understanding the deep flaws in a system that continues to perpetuate itself.
George Yancy, in his examination of Fanon notes that the white child’s finger, though seemingly innocent, is an expression of a deep, historic fear and misrecognition of Black bodies. It is by no means benign, Yancy asserts; “it takes its phenomenological or lived toll on the black body.” Baldwin’s white countrymen are similar to this child: "innocent" in their ignorance, but still complicit in the damage they cause. This innocence is part of the larger structure of racial oppression that they refuse to see.