Intersecting Journeys
-
Both texts by Habib and Abdulkarim represent some deeply personal and critical insights into identity, displacement, and resilience. Both authors navigate how their Muslim identities can reconcile with diaspora, societal expectations, and personal struggles with family relations.
Habib talks about the journey to reconcile his queer identity within the confines of being Muslim and cultural traditions. The Unity Mosque acts as that pivotal space wherein Habib reclaims their spirituality into an intersectional community. Similarly, Ali struggles with his identity as a queer Somali man facing displacement and alienation within both his family and Canadian society. However, his story tends to focus on the hard realities of survival, such as homelessness and systemic discrimination, zeroing in on the fragility of belonging when multiple identities meet in marginalized spaces.
Both authors highlight the tension between cultural heritage and personal authenticity. For Habib, this reconciliation comes through community-building and creative expression, while for Ali, the journey is more fraught, marked by unresolved familial estrangement and systemic barriers.
Family dynamics are front and centre in both stories, whether this is through the sense of hurt or growth. Habib talks about rejection by family because of expectations based on religion and culture, but his story, simultaneously, is full of hope for healing and understanding. On the other hand, Ali portrayed a more confrontational and raw family, with a strong description of betrayal, his father's remarriage, and his abandonment of responsibilities.
While Habib ultimately seeks connection and unity, Ali’s narrative focuses the impact of familial failures on his sense of self. This difference reflects broader questions about the role of family in shaping identity, whether it serves as a foundation for growth or an obstacle to overcome for growth.
Community becomes an important topic for both authors in their journeys. Habib finds comfort in spaces like Unity Mosque, which is a queer Muslim community where they find a sense of Islam that is accepting and affirming. This gives them the ability to find the missing links between their spiritual identity and queer identity and a way of finding a "chosen family." Community for Ali is highly fragmented meaning his connections with others are usually temporary based on shared struggles, not a sense of solidarity.
Both authors use storytelling as a way to convey resistance and healing. For Habib, photography and narrative become ways to strengthen underrepresented queer Muslim voices. Ali regards storytelling as a way of coping and working through trauma and giving voice to complicated experiences. In these ways, his writing reflects a general critique of the social norms that make queer immigrants vulnerable. Storytelling then becomes a way to be seen.
These stories are both deeply rooted in intersectionality because of their authors' own intersectional identities. Habib and Ali confront racism, homophobia, and Islamophobia which overlap.
Both authors show the battles of trauma in their lives. Habib's trauma was from religious rejection and social marginalization, which he works to heal through community and self-acceptance. Ali, on the other hand, confronts trauma from multiple fronts like familial abuse, societal discrimination, and the psychological toll of displacement.
I would like to use this as a credit for a missed discussion post please.