Was the Canadian points system non-discriminatory?
-
The Canadian points system introduced in 1967 was not truly non-discriminatory, despite its claims. While it appeared fair by using criteria like education, work skills, and language ability to evaluate immigrants, it actually created hidden barriers for many people.The text clearly states that "the emphasis on skills and education continued to discriminate against applicants from the developing world" (Muhammedi, 2022, p.79 ). This means that even though the system didn't openly discriminate based on race or nationality like earlier policies, it made it harder for people from developing countries to immigrate to Canada in other ways.
A key example from the readings shows how immigrants from India and East Africa faced significant problems. Even when these immigrants were well-educated and experienced, Canada often didn't recognize their qualifications. Many had to work in jobs below their skill level because their education and work experience from their home countries weren't accepted. This situation demonstrates how the points system favored people with Western education and work experience.
The system was particularly biased because it emphasized factors that people from developing countries often had less access to, like Western-style education and professional credentials. As the text explains, this created indirect discrimination. Even though Canada had officially removed racist policies and introduced multiculturalism in 1971, the points system still made immigration easier for some groups and harder for others based on where they came from. This discrimination is further highlighted in the case of Ugandan Asian expellees. While Canada accepted them partly for humanitarian reasons, the government emphasized their potential economic contribution and ability to integrate into Canadian society. The text mentions that they were viewed as "the most desirable type of immigrants" because many were well-educated and had business experience (Muhammedi, 2022, p. 78 ). This shows how the system continued to prioritize Western standards and economic benefits.
Therefore, while the points system was better than previous openly discriminatory policies, it wasn't truly non-discriminatory. It just changed how discrimination worked in the immigration system, making it less obvious but still effective in limiting opportunities for many potential immigrants.